|
CONTENTS |
Advie
Gundogs :
Pointer or setter?
- My pointers adjust range according to the game population
and the type of country. The pointers are easy to manage and are, frankly, my
favourites but setters are more instinctive in their work. Setters take longer
to train but they remember what they learn. My pointers are probably more
adaptable and forgiving. But please don't accept this as a general definition of
all pointers and setters -- my own dogs are not typical of the modern UK field
trialer although when competing Advie dogs were the ones the others had to beat. Tail Carriage - If you look at the old books on pointers and setters you will see tail carriage from the horizontal to about 45 degrees. I've never seen a 12 o'clock tail in these old pictures. So I'm not even going to discuss it. Sure, I like a reasonably high tail but to breed for the highest tail nature can produce is just plain silly. Another fancy point best consigned to the show bench. Then there is tail action. Some breeders say they want a dog with lots of tail action when it works. I mentioned this to a surgeon friend who responded with copies of pictures from a book on canine physiology. He pointed out that it was physically impossible for a dog to run fast and wag it's tail at the same time. Next time you see a greyhound or a cheetah on TV, notice how it's tail is used for balance when it is running -- but it doesn't wag it! Leave the tail wagging to the spaniels. High or Low Head
Carriage? - There are a lot of misconceptions about the head
carriage of a pointer or setter. Yes, we like to see a bird dog carry a high
head. Why? Because the exact location of game birds is best found from the
bird's body scent which is carried on the air
currents. So, two type of scent: Body scent which is carried in the air and ground scent left on the ground or vegetation. Obviously, air scent will be found above ground level. It can be so high that dogs will sometimes reach up on their hind legs to find it! But ground scent can also rise from the ground and be carried in the air. It isn't as strong and an experienced dog will know the difference. But do you? Confusing, isn't it? Because we want our dogs to point game where it is NOW and not where it was five minutes ago, we want our dogs to hunt for this air scent. Hence the general belief that a dog with a high head is the best dog. But supposing that air scent is at ground level? That is quite possible. If the bird is on the ground, the source of that air scent is also at ground level. Have you noticed how smoke from a fire hangs about at near ground level on a still cold evening? Isn't it logical that the dog should put his nose where the concentration of scent is greatest? Of course! And what is wrong with the dog checking ground scent to help him interpret air scent? What we don't want is for our dogs to try to locate birds by following ground scent, i.e. tracking, though even this will have it's uses as anyone who has hunted an old running grouse will know. The only rule is, Did it get game into the bag? Never mind the fancy points! I am afraid the subject of scent is
very complicated and not at all straight forward but I hope this now explains
why a dog with a low head may be quite correct for the conditions at that time!
The object is to find where the bird is NOW and provided the dog does not flush
before the sportsman can get up to shoot, it has done nothing wrong. If the dog
is using both air scent and ground scent to better locate those birds, I'd say
he was using his intelligence, wouldn't you? Temperament - I have long believed it is possible (but not necessarily easy) to breed a soft dog that is easy to train but that also hunts with speed, keenness, and style . I will leave it to others to breed dogs which need force training and electric collars. I have been breeding this soft, personable, birdy, almost self-training type of dog which also looks good for over thirty years. The hunting season is relatively short; you have to live with the dog for the rest of the year too. Range - Many hunters ask what is the range of these dogs. Used for hunting red grouse on the open moorland or pheasants and woodcock in the wooded glens, Advie pointers and setters hunt wide or close using their intelligence and experience to suit the terrain, the quantity of game, and the type of cover -- yet maintain contact with their handler. When fit, they have the courage and independence to hunt all day and every day of the season. They are intelligent good looking hunting companions, not hyper field trial dogs or posing show dogs -- their versatility has been demonstrated by their success for hunters world-wide yet they consistently win at trials too. See the links to my page on hunting. I expect the dogs to use their
brains and I would not bother feeding a dog that did not have the intelligence
to keep in touch. If they don't have the brain to realize who has the gun, what
am I keeping them for? Advie Annan, my pointer dog "Garry", will hunt out a
patch of rough grass a dozen yards square for some escaped game chicks and point
at a range of six inches. Not one chick will be harmed and he won't miss any.
But I can run him on the open mountain for grouse and he will cover a front
several hundred yards wide. But I also train
them
-- which may have something to do with it! To learn how, see
the videos and books on the Firth Productions
page or go to the page on Training for a short
description. Dr Adam Watson, the leading authority on red grouse in Scotland, has used Advie pointers to help him in his research work with The Institute of Terrestrial Ecology near Banchory, Aberdeenshire, for 23 years. My pointers are also used by Dr Steve Redpath's team that did the Langholm study into the effect of predation on a grouse moor. These dogs, purchased as young "started" dogs, were working on wild game to the scientists' complete satisfaction within just two weeks of leaving my kennels. Reporting - My pointers have a characteristic I recently learnt of in some strains of Scandinavian pointers. That is "reporting". If my dogs find and point game out of sight, they will occasionally leave the point, come and find me, then go back to resume the point! This has nothing to do with blinking or being soft on point but it is invaluable when hunting woodcock in bushy country. Visiting Advie
Gundogs
| Back to Top |
Previous Page | Next Page |
Home
| Derry Argue | Training | Hunting | Copyright Derry Argue © 2000
|